The Existentialist Republic

The Existentialist Republic

Nov. 16

Amid Reports of Frantic Trump Administration Destruction of Evidence, Legal and Investigative Experts Report Good News

Federal law makes destroying a government record a felony, and prosecutors have until November 2031 to charge anyone who shreds one in November 2026.

President Donald Trump, flanked by Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, at a mining industry roundtable at the State Department in D.C. on Aug. 7, 2026. Official White House photo by Joyce N. Boghosian, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Author’s note: This article is about 12 minutes long as audio. The Substack app reads it aloud from the play icon at the top right of the post.

Reports say Trump administration officials are frantically destroying evidence before Democrats take control of the House. CNN reported on Nov. 10, 2026, that several Interior Department whistleblowers went to Democrats on the House Natural Resources Committee with accounts of records being discarded. The records concern President Donald Trump’s construction projects in D.C., among them an arch near Arlington National Cemetery. The department’s answer was “100% false.”

A shredder destroys one copy of a document, and very little of this evidence exists as one copy. Deleted emails and texts can be recovered, banks have to keep their records for five years, the companies that dealt with the government keep their own files, some of the evidence is already public, and the people who watched the shredding can testify. The destruction of a federal record is itself a felony, so every official who shreds one, and every official who ordered it, becomes a defendant in a new case that the shredding created. A defendant facing prison has a reason to tell prosecutors who gave the order.

For this article I read federal banking rules, the criminal code, the record of the Iran-Contra investigation of the 1980s and what a former federal prosecutor and a former Homeland Security chief of staff said in November 2026, and I go through each of those points below.

The evidence will be there for the new Congress and for any prosecutor who wants it. Whether anyone goes to jail depends on who voters put in the offices that bring charges.

Democrats won control of the House on Nov. 3, 2026, and they take over its committees and their subpoena power when the new Congress is sworn in on Jan. 3, 2027.

Politico had already reported, on Aug. 7, 2026, the accounts of three Interior staffers who watched officials shred documents and set messages on the encrypted app Signal to disappear, and it quoted a former official saying, “They’re terrified of written records.”

Rep. Jared Huffman of California is the committee’s top Democrat and its expected chair in January 2027, and his answer to the whistleblowers was 36 preservation letters dated Nov. 9, 2026. A preservation letter tells its recipient to keep every record connected to an investigation. Nine of the letters are addressed to federal agencies, the Interior Department among them, and 27 to companies and nonprofits the committee has been investigating, including Lockheed Martin, John Deere, Mastercard and the Trust for the National Mall. Rep. Huffman told every recipient to “save everything.”

Rep. Huffman also directed recipients to recover anything already deleted and to confirm in writing that they are complying, CNN reported. The whistleblowers’ accounts are about the Interior Department.

Glenn Kirschner, a former career federal prosecutor, discussed the shredding reports on Nov. 10, 2026 on The Legal Breakdown, the show he hosts with Brian Tyler Cohen. “Almost nothing in government resides on paper and paper alone,” he said. In his own cases, forensic examiners restored emails and texts that defendants had deleted, and prosecutors then showed juries the message and the defendant’s attempt to delete it. His one exception was a message that was heavily encrypted from the start.

Kirschner compared the reports to the document destruction of Watergate and Iran-Contra, and the Iran-Contra investigation found the electronic trail he described. Independent counsel Lawrence Walsh, the prosecutor who investigated the affair, counted 736 messages deleted by Lt. Col. Oliver North, a National Security Council aide, and 5,012 deleted by National Security Adviser John Poindexter in the last week of November 1986, as the Reagan administration’s secret arms sales to Iran became public. The White House’s routine backup tapes had already saved the messages, and investigators read them.

Every construction project costs money, and money leaves a record at a bank. The Treasury Department sets five years as the retention period for the records banks must keep under the Bank Secrecy Act, the 1970 law that makes banks hold the records investigators use to trace money. A wire transfer of $3,000 or more made in November 2026 stays in the bank’s files until November 2031.

A congressional committee gets those records from the bank itself. House Republicans did that in their 2023 investigation of then-President Joe Biden’s family: the House Oversight Committee’s Democratic staff counted more than 14,000 pages of bank records held by the committee, including pages three banks produced under subpoena. The subpoena goes to the bank and the bank answers it.

The companies and nonprofits that dealt with the government hold a second set of files. CNN reported that Lockheed Martin and John Deere are among the donors to President Trump’s projects, and a donation exists in the donor’s own accounting records and email. Each of the 27 companies and nonprofits now holds a dated letter from the committee’s expected chair telling them what to keep.

Some of the evidence has been public for years. Elon Musk, who led the Department of Government Efficiency in 2025, wrote two posts on Twitter in May 2022 while he was buying the company, and a San Francisco federal jury found on March 20, 2026 that the posts were deceptive. The posts and the verdict are in a public court file. On Nov. 6, 2026, I wrote about how Texas can charge him over them.

Charles Borges, then the Social Security Administration’s chief data officer, wrote in a whistleblower complaint on Aug. 26, 2025 that a former Department of Government Efficiency official had the Social Security data of more than 300 million Americans copied into a private section of the agency’s cloud. NPR’s reporters read the agency’s own internal assessment of the risk and published what it says.

The destruction of the government’s copy is its own crime. Federal law sets up to three years in prison for anyone who willfully destroys a record filed in a public office, and an official who has custody of the record also loses the office and is barred from holding any federal office. A second law, passed in 2002 after accountants for the energy company Enron shredded their audit files, sets a maximum of 20 years for destroying a record to obstruct a federal investigation.

Watergate began as a burglary case with seven defendants. They stood trial in January 1973 for the break-in at the Democratic National Committee’s offices, and by the magazine History Revealed’s count the investigations that followed ended with 69 people charged and 48 found guilty, among them President Richard Nixon’s chief of staff and attorney general.

The deadline to bring those charges is five years. The shredding of a record in November 2026 can be charged until November 2031, almost three years after the next presidential term begins on Jan. 20, 2029.

A presidential pardon can erase that federal charge. The bank’s copy and the witness’s account stay where they are, and the pardoned official becomes a witness Congress can question.

Republicans put that argument to Dr. Anthony Fauci, the former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, at a Senate hearing on July 29, 2026. President Joe Biden had pardoned Fauci, and Sen. Josh Hawley of Missouri told him, “You don’t have any rights under the Fifth Amendment because you’ve been pardoned,” the Denver Gazette reported. The Supreme Court ruled in Brown v. Walker in 1896 that a witness has no Fifth Amendment privilege to claim for a pardoned offense. A witness can still claim the privilege where a state can prosecute the same conduct.

It takes people to shred a document, and each of them is a witness. The reporting on the Interior Department exists because people inside talked: three staffers to Politico in August 2026 and several whistleblowers to Rep. Huffman’s committee in the weeks before Nov. 10, 2026.

A Signal message set to disappear is the kind of encrypted record Kirschner excepted, and it still has a sender and a recipient who can be questioned under oath. Miles Taylor, the former Department of Homeland Security chief of staff who warned the public about President Trump anonymously in 2018, said on his Defiance Daily podcast on Nov. 10, 2026 that the people involved will be subpoenaed and deposed.

Taylor wrote on Nov. 12, 2026 that more Trump whistleblowers are thinking about coming forward, and he told them, “So don’t wait to be called as a witness.” Taylor’s advice is to go first to a whistleblower nonprofit such as Whistleblower Aid or the Government Accountability Project. Both help whistleblowers prepare a lawful, confidential disclosure.

The Supreme Court ruled in 2024 that presidents are immune from prosecution for official acts. Maritsa Georgiou, Taylor’s co-host, said on the same Nov. 10, 2026 episode that the ruling is for “the president, not for you at the paper shredder.”

What happens to a witness afterward decides how many come forward. The Partnership for Public Service, the nonprofit that surveyed 11,083 federal employees in late 2025, found that 22.5% trusted they could report lawbreaking without being punished for it.

On June 20, 2026, I wrote about why so few insiders speak and what states can do. A governor or a state attorney general can take reports through a lawyer so the whistleblower’s name stays secret, and the state can pay for the whistleblower’s legal defense. Either official can commit to both now, before any new law passes.

Each official who destroys a record this month to obstruct an investigation commits a felony punishable by up to 20 years in prison, chargeable until November 2031, and becomes a defendant with a reason to cooperate. Watergate began with seven defendants in a burglary case and ended with 48 people found guilty.

Whether those witnesses talk depends on whether anyone protects them, and today 22.5% of federal employees trust that they can report lawbreaking safely. A governor or a state attorney general can protect them now.

Buy the ER Some Coffee


CALL TO ACTION

Who you’re contacting and how: Reach out to one of your state legislators. You can do that by email, phone, FaxZero or even a printed letter. You could even go to their office during business hours, bring donuts, and tell the staff you’re going to talk to them about an issue you care about if the representative isn’t there.

Find your legislators by clicking on this sentence.

What you’re asking for: to publicly call on your governor and your state attorney general to pay the legal defense of anyone who reports federal lawbreaking to the state, and to open a confidential channel through a lawyer for those reports. You can read our article on how states can protect whistleblowers, even print it out and share it if you like, by clicking on this sentence.

Let them know who you are, what you want, and why you care. Offices count identical messages once, so write it in your own words.


Upgrade today and the Basic Decency Kit sticker sheet is free; the button is right under this sentence.

Buy the ER some coffee by clicking this sentence.

The Existentialist Republic Library

Buy a physical copy of Toppling Tyrants: A Field Guide to Dismantling American Fascism by clicking this sentence.

Get the FREE PDF of the book ($0.00) in the BMAC shop by clicking this sentence.

Toppling Tyrants: A Field Guide to Dismantling American Fascism

Our websites

The Existentialist Republic - the news site: every article, all 53 calls to action and all 11 model bills written for state legislators

The ER - the campaign hub: we publish the reporting, then the campaigns that come out of it, eight running now

The Activist Cipher - a free guided path to being an effective activist: which official to ask, what to ask for, and what to do with the answer; no email address required

Gavel Grab - the legal news publication I own and edit

ChristopherArmitage.com - my work in one place

The ER Store - books, journals, stickers, shirts, hats, mugs and posters

Books

Zombie Democracy: The Countries Still Voting After Elections Stopped Working - physical copy / free download

Conservatism: America’s Personality Disorder - physical copy / free download

The American Reformation: How States Can Use the Constitution to Break Authoritarian Capture - physical copy / free download

Intro to Soft Secession - physical copy / free download

Oppositional Federalism and You - physical copy / free download

Toppling Tyrants: A Field Guide to Dismantling American Fascism - physical copy / free download

Grab Them By The E.A.R.R.: How to Get Politicians to Do What You Want - physical copy / free download

Being Dangerous: Go From Activist to Operative - free download

WE REBEL: An Activist Journal - physical copy

More free downloads

Soft Secession: 100 Policies That Pass

Four Completed Model Legislation Bills (all 11 are on the site)

The Opposition Guide to Tax Warfare

Six-Panel Soft Secession Brochure

Prosecution Memo: Jonathan Ross

Bumper Stickers

Take the call to action →
Get new articles by email →