Nov. 19 · Corruption
7 State Treasurers and California’s Controller Signed a Warning About Elon Musk’s Tesla. Who Pays if the $1.5 Trillion Stock Falls?
Your State Treasurer Has a Fiduciary Obligation to Sell Tesla
Eight state financial officers signed a letter to Tesla’s board on April 17, 2025, saying the company’s performance “signals deeper governance and leadership challenges.” Public pension funds still hold billions of dollars of Tesla stock.
This article explores whether a compelling case can be made that investing public money in Tesla is a breach of fiduciary duty.
The officials who invest public money are state treasurers, comptrollers and the pension boards they sit on. My argument is that they are holding Tesla stock with that money after they have seen the evidence that it is an imprudent investment, and after some of them signed their names to that evidence. The law calls that a breach of fiduciary duty.
I make three points in this article. First, Tesla shows warning signs that a careful investor checks: collapsing earnings, a price near 400 times those earnings, a judge’s finding of deceptive marketing, a court’s findings about its board, large funds selling out, and a business that depends on government money. Second, the officials know, because they said so in letters they signed. Third, officials and advisers who kept other people’s money in an investment after warnings, and hid what they knew, have paid hundreds of millions of dollars, and one was sentenced to jail. A manager who showed a jury their process won.
Some of you manage money for a living and arrived ready to disagree. Here are your three best facts, before you have to raise them. Tesla’s stock rose more than 11% in 2025. Pension funds hold it because it is in the index. And in 2005 a Florida jury cleared the money manager who bought Enron stock for the state’s pension fund all the way down. I will answer each one with evidence.
A fiduciary is a person the law trusts to manage someone else’s money. In 2015 a unanimous Supreme Court wrote in Tibble v. Edison International that a trustee has “a continuing duty to monitor trust investments and remove imprudent ones.” Continuing means the duty did not end on the day the stock was bought. Remove means sell.
Which official has that duty depends on your state. In Connecticut the treasurer is the principal fiduciary of six state pension funds. In New York it is the state comptroller. In California the treasurer and the controller sit on the boards of the California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers’ Retirement System (CalSTRS), the two largest public pension funds in the country.
The money is public twice. It pays the retirements of teachers, nurses and state workers, and when a public pension fund comes up short, the state’s taxpayers cover the gap. After Florida’s fund lost $335 million on Enron, Sen. Bill Nelson, a Florida Democrat, reminded the Senate on Feb. 4, 2002, that the Florida plan was “guaranteed, not by the shareholders, but by the taxpayers.”
And the money is in Tesla. New York’s state fund reported 3.04 million Tesla shares worth $1.28 billion as of June 30, 2026, and New York City’s funds reported 3.1 million shares worth $1.25 billion at the end of January 2025. The American Federation of Teachers counts $8.8 billion in Tesla shares across the pension funds its members pay into.
1. The earnings. Tesla reported net income of $15.0 billion in 2023 and $3.8 billion in 2025. The 2023 figure includes a one-time tax benefit of $5.9 billion. Take that out and Tesla’s profit still fell by more than half in two years. In the third quarter of 2026 net income fell another 43% from a year earlier, to $787 million.
2. The sales. Tesla delivered 1.64 million vehicles in 2025, down from 1.79 million in 2024. That was its second straight annual decline, and it lost its place as the world’s largest electric carmaker to China’s BYD. In the first nine months of 2026, Tesla’s revenue was $8.74 billion higher than in the same months of 2025, and its net income was $576 million lower.
3. Where the profit comes from. In the first quarter of 2025 Tesla reported $409 million in net income and $595 million from regulatory credits, which are payments other carmakers make to Tesla under government emissions rules. Without that government program, the quarter was a loss. Governments have since restricted those programs, and in the third quarter of 2026 Tesla collected $113 million from regulatory credits, down 73% from a year earlier.
4. The price. Investors value Tesla at about $1.5 trillion, close to 400 times what the company earns in a year. Nobody pays that for a carmaker whose profits are falling. Tesla’s investors are paying for products Tesla has promised and does not yet sell at scale.
5. The promises. The product behind that price is the robotaxi, as well as a consistent history of other outlandish claims that never materialize but still boost stock prices. In 2019 Elon Musk told investors Tesla would have “over a million robotaxis on the road” by 2020. On Nov. 1, 2026, Tesla’s robotaxi fleet in Texas stood at 1,204 vehicles.
6. A judge’s finding. On Dec. 16, 2025, California administrative law judge Juliet Cox ruled that Tesla’s marketing of Autopilot and Full Self-Driving was deceptive and recommended suspending Tesla’s licenses to sell and build cars in the state for 30 days. The Department of Motor Vehicles said the cars “cannot now, operate as autonomous vehicles.” Tesla avoided the suspension in February 2026 by dropping the Autopilot name in California. A judge has ruled that Tesla misled the public about the same technology its stock price depends on.
7. The chief executive and the board. In 2018 the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged Musk with securities fraud over a tweet saying he had “funding secured” to take Tesla private. He and Tesla paid $40 million in penalties and he gave up the chairman’s seat.
In January 2024 Delaware’s Court of Chancery found that Musk controlled Tesla when it came to his own pay, in part through his close ties with the directors who negotiated it, and voided a package then worth $56 billion. In December 2025 the Delaware Supreme Court restored the pay because cancelling all of it was too harsh a remedy. Columbia Law School professor Dorothy Lund told CNBC that the ruling left the rest of the lower court’s decision intact. Six weeks before that ruling, the same board had won shareholder approval for a new pay package worth up to $1 trillion.
8. The professionals who left. ABP, the largest pension fund in the Netherlands, sold their entire €571 million Tesla stake in 2024. Denmark’s AkademikerPension announced in 2025 that they would sell their shares and blacklist the company. Their chief executive, Jens Munch Holst, said Musk’s conduct created “considerable risks to returns.”
9. The government money. The Washington Post counted at least $38 billion in government contracts, loans, subsidies and tax credits to Musk’s companies, including $11.4 billion in regulatory credits to Tesla. The $7,500 federal tax credit for buyers of electric cars expired in the fall of 2025. A company that needs this much public money to show a profit is exposed every time a government changes its mind.
Those are the warning signs. The second point is that the officials know.
On April 17, 2025, seven state treasurers and California’s controller wrote to Tesla’s board about the stock’s performance and about where Musk was putting his attention. That fall, the treasurers of Nevada, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Colorado, Vermont and New Mexico and Maryland’s comptroller co-signed a letter urging shareholders to vote against Tesla’s directors and against Musk’s pay. An Oct. 2, 2025, letter from state financial officers described directors with close personal and financial ties to Musk and steps the board had taken to suppress shareholder input.
They lost the vote on Nov. 6, 2025. The next day Connecticut Treasurer Erick Russell issued a statement saying there are “few examples of corporate mismanagement as egregious as Tesla’s” and calling the board’s conduct a risk to the retirement security of Connecticut’s teachers and state employees. He ended it by promising to keep engaging with the company.
The country’s largest pension fund went one step further. A CalPERS board member asked for a risk assessment on whether the fund should own Tesla at all. The board discussed it behind closed doors in March 2026, and afterward a board member announced that the board had “collectively agreed to make no changes at this time.”
The people who run a pension fund’s investments, or advise its board on the law, have arguments for keeping Tesla stock, and each one deserves an answer.
“We hold it because it is in the index.” CalSTRS has measured their portfolio against custom indexes that leave out tobacco companies since 2000, and their own divestment cost report describes the method. A fund that can track an index without tobacco can track one without Tesla. Holding the full index is a decision the board makes again every day it leaves the index alone.
“The market sets the price, and we are not paid to outguess it.” This is the strongest argument for keeping Tesla stock in a public pension fund. In Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer in 2014, the Supreme Court said claims that a fiduciary should have recognized from public information alone that a stock was overpriced are “implausible as a general rule, at least in the absence of special circumstances.” That rule protects a trustee from a lawsuit. It leaves the loss with the pension fund and with the taxpayers who guarantee the fund.
Tesla has special circumstances. The rule protects a trustee accused of failing to notice that a price was too high. These trustees noticed, wrote it down and signed it. And the public evidence about Tesla is more than a price: a judge’s finding of deception, a court’s findings about the board, and a fraud settlement with the SEC.
“The stock went up.” It did. On the way there it lost 45% of its value between January and early April of 2025. The law has the same answer in both directions. Ohio’s version of the Uniform Prudent Investor Act, like the versions most states have adopted, says a trustee’s compliance is judged by the facts at the time of the decision “and not by hindsight.” Fund managers rely on that rule every time one of their investments loses money. It applies with the same force when a decision made against the warnings gets lucky.
“We engage with companies. We don’t divest.” The treasurers engaged. They wrote the letters, they voted no, and the pay package passed anyway. Treasurer Russell’s answer to losing was a promise of more engagement with a board that, in his words, “rewards failure and silences dissent.” Engagement was tried in public, and it lost.
The third point is what has happened to people who kept other people’s money in an investment after the warnings.
Robert Citron was the elected treasurer of Orange County, California, and he invested the county’s money. In his last election his opponent charged that his returns came from risky betting. Citron won and kept the county’s money in those bets, and in December 1994 the county filed what was then the largest municipal bankruptcy in American history.
He pleaded guilty to six felonies, including making false statements in the sale of securities and misusing public funds, and was sentenced to a year in jail. The bets themselves were legal. What sent him to jail was what he told people about them and what he did with public money once they went bad.
Ivy Asset Management advised union pension plans in New York and was paid more than $40 million to check on their investments with Bernard Madoff. Their own checking found that Madoff was not investing the money the way he claimed. They kept their clients invested with Madoff. In 2012 they paid $210 million to settle with New York’s attorney general and the U.S. Department of Labor.
One case went the other way. Florida’s pension fund lost $335 million on Enron. Its outside manager, Alliance Capital, kept buying after one of its own analysts warned in mid-2001 that “something was about to blow up.” Florida sued, and on April 18, 2005, a jury found for Alliance on every claim.
Citron and Ivy hid what they knew from the people whose money it was, and they paid. Alliance convinced a jury that they had followed their process, and they won on every claim. The officials holding Tesla have hidden nothing. They published their alarm under their own signatures. That puts them where none of those defendants stood: the record of what they knew is complete, and they wrote it themselves. The file is missing the analysis showing why a prudent investor who believes what they signed would stay in.
Trustees have a continuing duty to monitor the investment and remove it if it is imprudent. They have nine warning signs in front of them. Their own statements call the mismanagement egregious and describe a board tied to Musk. They tried to fix the company from the inside and lost the vote. After that a trustee has two moves: sell, or produce the analysis that justifies staying.
CalPERS made their choice behind a closed door. Connecticut promised more engagement. Neither one is a sale, and neither one is an analysis the public can read.
I asked at the start whether a compelling case can be made that investing public money in Tesla is a breach of fiduciary duty. My answer is yes. Tesla earned 43% less last quarter than it did a year earlier, and investors still price the company near 400 times its yearly earnings. Some of the officials who keep public money in that stock signed their own warnings about the company in 2025. Every official who holds it owes the public a sale or a published analysis, and any resident of their state can ask for one.
Upgrade today; the button is right under this sentence.
CALL TO ACTION
Who you’re contacting and how: Your state treasurer, or your state comptroller if that office invests your state’s money. An email, phone call, letter, or fax all work. Invite a friend to multiply the influence of the action.
Find your state’s treasurer or comptroller by clicking on this sentence.
What you’re asking for:
1. A public answer on whether your state holds Tesla stock with public money, and how much.
2. If your state holds it, a sale of the stock or a published analysis that justifies holding it.
Send this article with your message. Eight state financial officers signed a letter to Tesla’s board in 2025 about the company’s performance, and Connecticut Treasurer Erick Russell called Tesla’s mismanagement egregious. A state that keeps public money in Tesla after those warnings has a problem, and it looks corrupt or inept.
Let them know who you are, what you want, and why you care. Offices count identical messages once, so write it in your own words.
Buy the ER some coffee by clicking this sentence.
The Existentialist Republic Library
Get the FREE PDF of the book ($0.00) in the BMAC shop by clicking this sentence.
Our websites
The Existentialist Republic - the news site: every article, all calls to action and all model bills written for state legislators
The ER - the campaign hub: we publish the reporting, then the campaigns that come out of it, eight running now
The Activist Cipher - a free guided path to being an effective activist: which official to ask, what to ask for, and what to do with the answer; no email address required
Gavel Grab - our dedicated legal news and accountability publication
ChristopherArmitage.com - my work in one place
The ER Store - books, journals, stickers, shirts, hats, mugs and posters
Books
Zombie Democracy: The Countries Still Voting After Elections Stopped Working - physical copy / free download
Conservatism: America’s Personality Disorder - physical copy / free download
The American Reformation: How States Can Use the Constitution to Break Authoritarian Capture - physical copy / free download
Intro to Soft Secession - physical copy / free download
Oppositional Federalism and You - physical copy / free download
Toppling Tyrants: A Field Guide to Dismantling American Fascism - physical copy / free download
Grab Them By The E.A.R.R.: How to Get Politicians to Do What You Want - physical copy / free download
Being Dangerous: Go From Activist to Operative - free download
WE REBEL: An Activist Journal - physical copy
More free downloads
Soft Secession: 100 Policies That Pass
Four Completed Model Legislation Bills (all 10 are on the site)
The Opposition Guide to Tax Warfare
Six-Panel Soft Secession Brochure




