Nov. 20 · Corruption
New York AG Letitia James Has Everything She Needs to Put Elon Musk in Prison
New York’s Martin Act requires no proof that anyone lost money, and no president can pardon a state conviction.
Quote from the article: “For those who might say “well Trump and his administration are not above using unlawful coercive and retributive methods to get their way” my response would be “good” because that can also be documented and prosecuted by New York State officials. The whole process turns into a litmus test, a sort of autocratic honey trap for identifying corrupt federal officials.”
Elon Musk spent at least $474 million on the midterm elections of November 3, 2026, and the Republicans he backed lost both chambers of Congress. Musk told The New York Times DealBook Summit on November 18, 2026, “I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money.”
On that same Election Day, New York voters re-elected Attorney General Letitia James to a third term. Her office enforces something called the Martin Act, a powerful New York securities fraud law that requires no proof that an investor relied on a false statement or lost money as a prerequisite for an Attorney General to launch investigations.
This article explores what her office could charge Musk with under that law, and I begin with what a Delaware court has already found.
In January 2024, Delaware Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick examined the evidence behind Elon Musk’s fifty-six billion dollar compensation package and found fraud.
Tesla’s proxy materials told shareholders the directors who approved the package were independent. They were not. The Compensation Committee chair had known Musk for fifteen years. Another committee member carried a twenty-year business relationship with him, vacationed with him regularly, and attended his wedding. Tesla’s general counsel was Musk’s former divorce attorney, a man who grew emotional during his deposition when discussing his client. The proxy statement called these directors independent, and the court found that description inaccurate enough to be fraudulent.
Quick note from Chris: The We Rebel Docuseries has editors and film crew to pay, this project is independent thanks to being 100% reader funded. Can you chip in to help us complete the first episode? Just click this sentence to keep the project moving forward!
Enjoy the rest of the article - Chris
To be clear, a state court examined the evidence, a judge labeled it fraud, and Musk’s lawyers did what the most expensive lawyers in the country are paid to do: find the procedural technicality that lets their client keep the money.
On December 19, 2025, the Delaware Supreme Court reversed the remedy without disturbing those findings. The plaintiff’s lawyers had asked for complete rescission, and the court decided that remedy went too far. America, the land where the highest courts do favors for the richest man on earth when things don’t go his way.
The decision restored the entire package, worth about one hundred thirty-nine billion dollars at the close of trading that day. Conveniently for Mr. Musk, this decision was not widely reported. The factual findings of proxy fraud stood but the richest man in the world kept the money anyway.
Some would say that every mechanism so far that was designed to hold Elon Musk accountable has a technicality his lawyers have successfully exploited, and they have exploited every single one. Some would say that this is not an accident, that the legal code is built with these complexities to benefit those who can afford armies of lawyers.
The result for someone like Musk generally looks like the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) settling for pocket change and requiring no admission of wrongdoing. For Musk this looks like civil juries applying standards demanding proof of reliance and damages, Delaware then finding fraud and restoring the compensation because the remedy was too extreme. Each system offers a technicality, and Musk’s lawyers have found it. The Martin Act offers no such technicality.
This report documents securities fraud violations by Elon Musk under New York’s Martin Act. Count by count, the statutory maximums add up to more than one hundred years in state prison. Every piece of evidence cited here comes from federal court filings, SEC complaints, state administrative rulings, and Musk’s own public statements. The underlying facts are fully public, but the charges have not been brought.
Yet.
A Martin Act conviction requires proof of one thing for a misdemeanor: that someone made a false statement or omitted a material fact in connection with securities, or engaged in conduct that deceives or tends to deceive the public. Intent, reliance, completed transactions, proven losses: none of these are elements of the offense. For a felony, the state must show intent to defraud through a systematic scheme targeting ten or more people. A Class B felony in New York carries eight and one third to twenty-five years in state prison.
The Martin Act reaches any securities fraud that touches New York, and Musk’s conduct runs through the state like a live wire, as does most of the fraudulent and criminal conduct of this administration. This is because Tesla trades on NASDAQ, which is headquartered in New York. Every share of Tesla stock bought or sold on that exchange constitutes a securities transaction in New York. Every public statement Musk makes that moves Tesla’s price on a New York exchange is a statement made in connection with securities traded in New York, which is all the Martin Act requires. SpaceX has traded on NASDAQ under the ticker SPCX since June 12, 2026. Twitter traded on the New York Stock Exchange before Musk took it private. The jurisdictional question answers itself: if the fraud touches a New York exchange, New York can prosecute and the President of the United States cannot intervene through lawful measures.
For those who might say “well Trump and his administration are not above using unlawful coercive and retributive methods to get their way” my response would be “good” because that can also be documented and prosecuted by New York State officials. The whole process turns into a litmus test, a sort of autocratic honey trap for identifying corrupt federal officials.
Now what we will review together is a decade of false statements by Musk, all of which are sufficient for investigations by at least one state government and carry at least some appearance of criminally prosecutable conduct of Musk. Each one produced an accountability mechanism that failed. Each failure of accountability traces back to a technicality the Martin Act does not offer.
On August 7, 2018, Musk told his 22 million Twitter followers: “Am considering taking Tesla private at $420. Funding secured.” The SEC complaint established that Musk had not secured funding. He had attended one meeting with Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund, lasting thirty to forty-five minutes, that covered none of the basics: no dollar amounts, no acquisition premiums, no ownership percentages. He told the SEC that he rounded the price up to $420 because he had recently learned about the number’s significance in marijuana culture and thought his girlfriend “would find it funny, which admittedly is not a great reason to pick a price.”
Tesla’s stock rose more than six percent that day. Musk had not notified the NASDAQ exchange before posting, violating rules requiring ten minutes advance notice for market-moving announcements. He consulted no one on Tesla’s board, no legal counsel, no financial advisor. Seventeen days later, he abandoned the plan entirely.
Two accountability mechanisms engaged, and both failed. The SEC settled with Musk and Tesla for forty million dollars combined. Musk stepped down as board chairman for three years and agreed to have a securities lawyer pre-approve any future statements about Tesla that could move markets. This has not occurred and there have been no mechanisms to ensure compliance or penalize lack of compliance by Musk. Later, in May 2020, he tweeted “Tesla stock price is too high imo” without pre-approval, and the stock fell as much as thirteen percent that day. A California jury later cleared him in a civil suit, deliberating for less than two hours.
Musk promised autonomous driving on a timeline that escalated with each failure. A coast-to-coast self-driving trip by end of 2017 became one million robotaxis by 2020, then Level 5 full autonomy that same year, then unsupervised Full Self-Driving in Texas and California by 2025. When 2025 arrived, Tesla operated a limited pilot program with human safety monitors sitting inside the vehicles. None of the promised timelines came true. The first Austin rides with no safety monitor in the car came on January 22, 2026, “a few unsupervised vehicles mixed in with the broader robotaxi fleet,” while Tesla’s Bay Area service kept safety drivers behind the wheel.
On December 16, 2025, the California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) said what securities regulators had declined to say. Administrative Law Judge Juliet Cox found Tesla’s marketing of its Full Self-Driving (FSD) technology constituted deceptive practices, calling Tesla’s claims “actually, unambiguously false and counterfactual.” Tesla dropped the Autopilot name in the United States in January 2026, and the DMV confirmed on February 17, 2026 that the change spared Tesla a thirty-day suspension of its dealer license. Tesla had already filed suit on February 13, 2026 to erase the finding.
The deception extends beyond software promises to hardware demonstrations. In October 2024, Musk held an event called “We, Robot” where he unveiled the Cybercab and displayed Optimus humanoid robots interacting with attendees. Bloomberg reported four days later that employees stationed elsewhere controlled many of the robots remotely. Milan Kovac, the head of the Optimus program, admitted the robots were “human assisted to some extent.” At a December 2025 event in Miami, an Optimus robot fell backward while handing out water bottles, and video captured it mimicking a human operator removing a VR headset before falling. Tesla presented these robots to investors as demonstrations of autonomous artificial intelligence. They were controlled by people in another room.
In early 2022, Musk began buying Twitter shares. By March 14, he owned more than five percent of the company. Federal securities law required disclosure within ten calendar days. Musk filed on April 4, eleven days late. During those eleven days, he purchased more than five hundred million dollars worth of additional stock while the price remained suppressed because the market did not know what he was doing. The SEC calculated that his delayed disclosure allowed him to underpay by at least one hundred fifty million dollars.
Are we supposed to believe that the richest man on Earth doesn’t have attorneys advising these decisions? Or is it possible that he does have attorneys who explained “you’ll make more money by breaking the rule than you will be fined or charged as a result of breaking it”?
The SEC filed suit in January 2025. On February 3, 2026, a federal judge denied Musk’s motion to dismiss, rejecting every constitutional argument his lawyers raised. In May 2026 the SEC settled anyway. A trust in Musk’s name paid a $1.5 million penalty; Musk admitted nothing and kept the one hundred fifty million dollars. In July 2026 U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan approved the deal while writing that the court had “significant misgivings about the settlement reached in this case.” The eleven-day delay is the offense, and the one hundred fifty million dollars is the motive a prosecutor can prove but does not even need.
Here is what the evidence supports: Grand Larceny in the First Degree based on the Twitter disclosure, a Class B felony carrying eight and one third to twenty-five years. Martin Act felonies for schemes to defraud investors through false FSD statements, false proxy statements, misrepresentations about Optimus, and concealment of the Twitter stake, each a Class E felony carrying one and one third to four years. Multiple Martin Act misdemeanors for individual false statements. Count by count, those maximums add up to more than one hundred years. New York Penal Law 70.30 caps consecutive sentences at thirty years when one of the convictions is a Class B felony, so thirty years is the most a New York judge could impose on these counts together.
So what are the defenses Musk and Co have levied? That the FSD promises are protected by safe harbor, except safe harbor covers good-faith projections, not statements a state administrative body has ruled were lies or a pattern of wild claims wholly out of reach to a degree that makes some people ask “how much difference is there between Elon Musk and Elizabeth Holmes of Theranos fame?”
A jury already acquitted him, but that civil jury in California applied a standard requiring proof of reliance and damages; the Martin Act requires neither. The SEC already settled, but dual sovereignty means a state can prosecute crimes the federal government resolved civilly; New York prosecuted Trump for conduct federal prosecutors declined to touch. The Delaware case was reversed, but the Supreme Court reversed the remedy, not the factual findings; the court restored Musk’s compensation because it deemed rescission too extreme, not because it found Tesla’s disclosures were accurate. No one has ever gone to prison under the Martin Act for this, and that is a choice prosecutors have made, not a limitation the statute imposes.
Currently, people in the United States are living through the consequences of the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s post-9/11 shift away from investigating corruption and white collar crime towards a focus on terrorism.
No wonder things have deteriorated so rapidly.
That shift has led to two and a half decades of no serious and reliable force stepping into those spaces and the results speak for themselves. If we want this to change, we have the tools at our disposal immediately for anyone serious about changing things for the better and creating accountability among the most powerful and corrupt among our nation.
Political reality presents the practical obstacle. Elon Musk is the richest person on earth, with a net worth of about $907 billion on November 19, 2026. He spent $288 million to help elect the current president and ran the Department of Government Efficiency until May 2025. For the 2026 midterms he was the top donor of the cycle, and the party he funded lost both chambers of Congress.
The attorney general who would bring a Martin Act case, Letitia James, was herself indicted by a federal grand jury in October 2025 on charges widely understood as retaliation for her prosecution of Trump. A judge dismissed the indictment in November 2025. Even though the courts have been striking these charges down, they still impose a cost on Attorney General James. So why would she or any other prosecutor risk the same outcome? They should, we need them to, but if they don’t win or lose elections based off that decision then they only have Trump’s disincentive to investigate. I thank New York Attorney General Letitia James for her work.
Still, the fact remains that civil suits have not yet proven to be enough to stop the Trump regime or put the United States back on track. They are a necessary part of the process but not a sufficient one. We need criminal prosecutions and we have already seen that delaying prosecutions based on electoral outcomes is a failed strategy. Further, we have seen that federal agencies are now complicit in the Trump criminal enterprise.
We created the FBI, DOJ, and SEC to fight back in cases where the KKK ran southern police departments, when politicians were accepting bribes, and when white collar criminals were fleecing the public for billions of dollars.
In the absence of that enforcement we must urgently fill the shortfall of enforcement.
A final question, what do we lose by having cities and states fill that gap? Has the current system worked out very well? Should we keep trying the same thing over and over on a two to four year cycle of boom and bust, hope and despair, where we live or die based off a single election?
The fact is that the Martin Act requires no federal cooperation and no proof of reliance or damages. A presidential pardon cannot reach a state conviction. Every technicality that has allowed Musk to walk away from a decade of documented securities fraud does not exist under this statute.
New York Attorney General Letitia James has the authority to open a Martin Act investigation tomorrow morning. She can issue subpoenas, compel testimony, and bring criminal charges based entirely on state law. She does not need the SEC, the DOJ, or any federal official to sign off. She needs only to decide that documented securities fraud by the richest man in the world deserves the same treatment as documented securities fraud by anyone else. Perhaps even more due to the incredible extent of the possible damages.
We must end the era of presumption and tolerance of a justice system that finds infinite leniency for the haves and deeply punitive decisions for the have nots.
Buy the ER some coffee by clicking this sentence.
CALL TO ACTION
Who you’re contacting and how: New York Attorney General Letitia James. You do not have to live in New York to write to her office. Her office takes messages through its contact page and by phone at 1-800-771-7755. A mailed letter goes to the Office of the New York Attorney General, The Capitol, Albany, NY 12224-0341. Invite a friend to multiply the influence of the action.
Reach the Attorney General’s office through its contact page by clicking on this sentence.
What you’re asking for: a public announcement that her office has opened a Martin Act investigation into Elon Musk’s statements to investors about Tesla and his purchase of Twitter.
Send this article with your message. The Martin Act is New York’s securities fraud law, and it lets the attorney general subpoena records and witnesses before any charge is filed. You can read the Martin Act’s criminal section by clicking on this sentence.
Let them know who you are, what you want, and why you care. Offices count identical messages once, so write it in your own words.
The Existentialist Republic Library
Get the FREE PDF of the book ($0.00) in the BMAC shop by clicking this sentence.
Our websites
The Existentialist Republic - the news site: every article, all calls to action and all model bills written for state legislators
The ER - the campaign hub: we publish the reporting, then the campaigns that come out of it, eight running now
The Activist Cipher - a free guided path to being an effective activist: which official to ask, what to ask for, and what to do with the answer; no email address required
Gavel Grab - our dedicated legal news and accountability publication
ChristopherArmitage.com - my work in one place
The ER Store - books, journals, stickers, shirts, hats, mugs and posters
Books
Zombie Democracy: The Countries Still Voting After Elections Stopped Working - physical copy / free download
Conservatism: America’s Personality Disorder - physical copy / free download
The American Reformation: How States Can Use the Constitution to Break Authoritarian Capture - physical copy / free download
Intro to Soft Secession - physical copy / free download
Oppositional Federalism and You - physical copy / free download
Toppling Tyrants: A Field Guide to Dismantling American Fascism - physical copy / free download
Grab Them By The E.A.R.R.: How to Get Politicians to Do What You Want - physical copy / free download
Being Dangerous: Go From Activist to Operative - free download
WE REBEL: An Activist Journal - physical copy
More free downloads
Soft Secession: 100 Policies That Pass
Four Completed Model Legislation Bills (all 10 are on the site)
The Opposition Guide to Tax Warfare
Six-Panel Soft Secession Brochure




